Genealogy: Sutton, Dudley, and Winthrop

This genealogy of the Sutton, Dudley and Winthrop ancestors of Frederick Wickham is an excerpt from the transcription of a handwritten notebook I discovered in my grandmother’s papers. The family history in this notebook was the work of two women, Agnes Caroline Wickham and her daughter, Harriott Benedict Wickham Barton (my grandmother), who separately researched and made entries in it over a period of seventy years.  Agnes Wickham wrote roughly half of the entries in the notebook from 1909 to 1915.  In 1915, she gave handwritten copies of her work to each of her five children: Eleanor, William, Lucy, David and Harriott.  Harriott continued her mother’s work off and on for the next sixty years, adding entries as late as 1977.

Dave Barton

Sutton, Dudley, and Winthrop Genealogy

Sutton and Dudley Families

(From Dudley Genealogy, Vol. I – by Deane Dudley)

Pedigree of Sutton upon Lieutenant Colonel of Nottingham, England.

1.  Hervey, the Saxon tenant of Earl Alan of Sudton, or South town, 14 William I (A.D. 1079 (2) — his son (3) — grandson.

4.  Hervey de Sutton, A.D. 1175, (5) Rowlaudde Sutton; died before 1259; married Alice, sister of John, Lord Lexington.

6.  Sir William de Sutton, born in reign of Henry III; married Matilda.

7.  Sir Robert de Sutton of Warsop and Acton, Kt.; born 1240; died 1273; married Johanna.

8.  Sir Richard de Sutton of Warsop and Acton; born September 29, 1266.  “Arms: On a lion rampart, a forked tail weret.” Married Isobel.

9.  Sir John de Sutton; died 1338; Lord of Dudley, 1326, in right of his wife, Margaret de Someri, born 1289, daughter of Roger de Someri, Lord Dudley; she died 1300.

10. Sir John de Sutton; married before 1329, Isabelde Charlton, daughter of John of Baton Powys, M.P. 1342.  Seal: 2 lions pass. In pale.

11. Sir John de Sutton, in wars in France; married (2) Joane or Jane, daughter of John de Clinton or Charlton, seized of Malpas lauds.

12.  John de Sutton, died August 8.  Henry IV in 1406 seized his father’s lands; married (2) Constance, daughter of Sir Walter Blount of Barton County, Derby.

13.  Sir John Sutton, Lord Dudley, born 1401; died 13 September 1487.  K.J. and Lord Lieutenant of Ireland; married Elizabeth, daughter of Sir John Berkeley of Beverston, Gloucestershire.


14.  Edmund Sutton, or Dudley, died 1485, before his father; married (1) Joyce, sister & co-heir of John Liptoft, Earl of Worchester.

15.  Sir Edward, Lord Dudley, K.J., Baron Dudley,; married Cecilia, daughter of Sir William Willoughby.

16.  Thomas Dudley; married Margaret who died 1551 – he died 1549 in London. “citizen and Draper of London.”  A freeholder in Drapers’ Guild.

17.  John Dudley, died 1545, buried at St. Michael’s, Cornhill, London.  Was of the Drapers’ Company.  Citizen & freeholder of London.  Married Elizabeth Clerke, daughter of John; died 1563.

18.  Captain Roger Dudley, slain at Battle of Irry, 1590; married Susanna Thorne, mother of Thomas Dudley, was daughter of Thomas and Mary (Purefoy) Thorne of Yardley.  Mary Purfoy was daughter of Edward & Anne (Phettiplow) Purefoy.  Edward Purefoy was born in Effield, June 13, 1494 & died at Shalston, June 1, 1558.  He was son of Nicholas Purefoy, whose pedigree reaches back to 1277.  Anne Phettiplace, daughter of Richard Phettiplace, born July 16, 1496 at Shireford, Parva and died 1568. (N.E. Genealogical Register)

19.  Thomas Dudley, born October 12, 1576; Married Yardley Hastings at Northamptonshire; died in Roxbury, Massachusetts, July 31, 1653; married (1) Dorothy Yorke, daughter of Edmond of Cotton End, near Northamption, England, who died at Roxbury in 1643; married (2) Katherine Dighton, widow of Samuel Hackburne; she died in 1671.

He was an officer of Queen Elizabeth, serving in Holland.  Later he became a Puritan.  He retrieved the fortune of the Earl of Lincoln by care of his estate as steward.  Came to Massachusetts on the Arabella with John Winthrop, as Deputy Governor in 1630.  Was Governor of Massachusetts Colony, 1634, 40, 45, 50.  Was Lieutenant Colonel of 1st Militia.  Governor Winthrop being Colonel.  Was first Major General of Militia, 1644.  He was a quarrelsome man, very set in his opinions.  “Produced progeny at age 70.”

20. Joseph, born September. 23, 1647; died at Roxbury, April 2, 1720.  Married Rebecca Lyng, daughter of Judge Edward (first Lyng in America) and Mary Lyng.  Rebecca was born January 15, 1647 at Boston.  Joseph graduated from Harvard 1665.  Served in Indian War, 1675.  Went to England as agent for the Province 1682.  President of New England, 1686, but was superceded by Andoos soon after and made Chief Justice of New York in 1693.  Later he was Lieutenant Governor of the Isle of Wight.  Governor of Massachusetts 1702-1715.

21.  Anne, born 1684; married John Winthrop, December 16, 1707;  died August 1, 1747.

[The following is from the Winthrop Genealogy Page]

IV.  John, born August 28, 1681.  Graduated at Harvard College 1700.  Was a Fellow of the Royal Society.  Resided much in England.  His home was in Boston & New London.  He married Ann Dudley, daughter of Governor Joseph and Rebecca (Lyng) Dudley of Massachusetts, December 16, 1707.  She was born August 27, 1684.  He died August 1, 1747.

1.  Mary, born September 18, 1708; died about March 1767.

2.  John Still, born January 15, 1720; died June 6, 1776.

V.  Mary, born September 18, 1708; married Joseph Wanton, August 21, 1729; died March 1767.

1.  Elizabeth, married Thomas Wickham, December 22, 1762.

[The following is from the Wickham Genealogy Page]

4.  Thomas, born April 5, 1736; married Elizabeth Wanton, December 22, 1762; died, March 21, 1817. (1) Admitted as freeman 1759.  In 1778 was paid 30 pounds for a whale boat by the state.  About 1881, when thrown into jail because of sympathy for England, his father-in-law was Colonial Governor for King, he presented to the assembly a petition praying to be released from prison, and payment of 5,000 silver dollars, to be restored to full citizenship.  Assembly gave him freedom of Newport upon payment of 500 silver dollars and bonds for his good behavior during the war.  January 1782, he prayed for permission to go to New York in interest of his distressed family.  Assembly allowed this, if in return he agreed to procure copies of accounts from books of Joseph and William Wanton at New York, as committee may request, and if Joseph and William Wanton do not allow him to examine books, and make copies of same, the Assembly will take estate which they now permit Mrs. Sarah Wanton, widow of late Joseph Wanton, Esq., to enjoy for her comfort and the education of her children. (4) In 1784 a petition was presented for restoration of a house and land, etc. to Thomas Wickham, his wife Elizabeth & other heirs of Joseph Wanton, and a committee was appointed to look into matter (report not given).  In 1791 Thomas Wickham with others of Trinity Church, Newport, petition Assembly to allow them to have a lottery, the proceeds to make much needed repairs on church.

1.  Thomas, born November 7, 1763.

2.  Mary Winthrop, born May 22, 1772

3.  Elizabeth, born November 2, 1773

4.  Catherine, born January 23, 1775

5.  John, born April 2, 1785

6.  William, born July 7, 1778 – served in U.S. Navy, March 1798.

7.  Ann, born April 2, 1785 – Died at Sodus Point, N.Y

8.  Thomas, born April 2, 1785 – Married Katherine Rutger.  This must be “Aunt Katie” in Angelica’s poem about the house.

All above were natives of Newport, R.I.

5.  William, born July 7, 1778; married Catherine Christian, (daughter of Frederick & Elizabeth Hodgkinson Christian) March 24, 1803;  died at Sodus point, New York, May 1875.  He went to sea when 13 years old – sailed all over the world and at 21 was Captain of a ship.  The old spy glass was his, and the scratch on one of the lenses was made by a passenger when on a trip home from Russia.  Frank Wickham told me that William had a chance (even signed up) to go on the ill-fated Astor expedition (as 1st Mate, I think), but Catherine objected so strenuously that he gave it up.  The ship reached Oregon, but all on board were killed there, presumably by Indians. Abandoning the sea, he went into business in New York with his brother Thomas as an importing merchant.  They had a shipping business in New York after 1803.  Their ships sailed to the West Indies and one was lost on a return voyage.  In 1807, when President Jefferson put the Embargo on U.S. shipping out of U.S. ports, they had a ship loaded, ready to sail.  Being in hard circumstances, they took a chance, sent the ship out and it was caught and confiscated with its cargo.  This ruined them.  William then went to wilderness shore of Lake Ontario and built a cabin, moving his family up there about 1812 (the year his son, my grandfather, Fredrick was born in New York City).  William had fishing boats and nets there.  The British raided from Canada, burning his cabin, boats, and nets.  The U.S. Government reimbursed all settlers who swore they stayed to defend their property, but William refused to lie (as others did), so had no relief, until, in later years, Congress granted to him and his descendants the right to fish in Lake Ontario forever, regardless of season.  William & Katherine buried in the woods during the raid their silver, including, I think, a tea set given by Queen Anne to William’s ancestor for service to the Queen with their ships out of Rhode Island (Queen Anne’s War). (5)

William Wickham married Catherine Christian in 1803.  She lived in Philadelphia. Her father, Frederick Christian had married Elizabeth Hodgkinson. (6) Elizabeth’s father, or grandfather, John Hodgkinson, according to family legend, was originally John Erskine, Earl of Mar, who took part in the Jacobite insurrections in Scotland in early 1700’s, was in the conspiracy to restore the old Stuart “pretender” to the throne, was captured, escaped to Ireland (where he changed his name to Hodgkinson) then to America. (See Webster Biographical Dictionary).

“There was a young man in Philadelphia who was attentive to me, and while I couldn’t say I loved him, I thought more of him than of any other young man I knew. One day he invited me to go horse back riding and I felt that day he was going to ask me to marry him, and I had made up my mind to accept him. Just as I came downstairs in my riding habit, my brother came into the house with a young man whom he introduced to me as Captain Wickham.  I knew right then I was going to refuse the other young man that afternoon, and I did.  Later your grandfather asked me and we have been lovers ever since.”  Told by Katherine Christian + Wickham (daughter of Frederick & Elizabeth * Hodgkinson Christian) to Sara Wickham of Huron, Erie County, Ohio. (They were married in Christ Church, Philadelphia).

+ The Christians were Flemish people who had settled in Philadelphia.

* Elizabeth Hodgkinson was a granddaughter of Lord Erakeyre, Earl of Man, who (about 1816) lost his title because of his part in the attempt to put the Stuart “Pretender” back on the throne.  He fled to Ireland and changed his name to Hodgkinson.

1.  Elizabeth Wanton, born December 22, 1803; married Alden S. Baker; died February 4, 1892.

2.  John William, born 1806, died 1893?; married (1) Marial (2) Sarah (3) Elizabeth Van Ransellaer; died 1893. Father of Schuyler Wickham.  Cousin Schuyler, of Huron, Ohio.  My father took me (not quite three years old) to visit them.  Uncle John was very old, long white hair – sat by the window & looked sadly down the river (which was back of their house).  Handsome man.

3.  Thomas, born 1808; married (1) Proseus, (2) Frances Shipley.

4.  Samuel Christian, born 1810 (died young)

5.  Frederick, born March 11, 1812; married Lucy Preston (my grandparents).

6.  Samuel Christian, born 1819 (died)

7.  Samuel Christian, born 1824; married Gertrude Van Ransellaer.  My “Aunt Gertie” Van Rensellaer Wickham had summer house in Huron, Ohio (very interesting old lady).

6.  Frederick, born March 11, 1812; married Lucy Preston, June 15, 1835 at Norwalk, Ohio; died January 12, 1901; buried at Norwalk. (7) In early life a sailor on the Great Lakes, but gave it up at request of his wife.  At time of marriage was captain of a schooner, DeWitt Clinton, owned by himself and brother John.  Baptized as infant in St. John’s Episcopal Church in New York City.  Brought up at Sodus, New York.  Came to work in Norwalk, Ohio in store of Wickham, Alling & Christian (relatives).  Returned to sailing.  Last trip he left his boat at Perrysburg, Ohio in December 1834, 5 or before, and walked most of way to Norwalk; there went to work in office of Norwalk Reflector, belonging to his father-in-law.  He later became owner and editor of the paper.  Having lived in early life in the wilderness of western New York, he had no education, could not read nor write until grown up.  He then acquired an education and was one of best known editors of Northern Ohio for more than 50 years.  Was Associate Judge of Court of Common Pleas in Huron County, Ohio, Mayor of Norwalk – member of State Senate during Civil War. (8) Soon after coming to Norwalk, he was very homesick, walking with an acquaintance, he passed a yard where a girl was picking flowers.  He was introduced and was given a flower.  He later says his homesickness vanished immediately.  The girl was Lucy Preston, later his wife.  His son recalls that he spoke of that incident to his wife the day before her death. (9) Their home was the large white house with two-story vine covered porch, on the north side of West Main Street, Norwalk, just east of the library.  Said to have been a wedding present to Lucy from her brother.  Now the Firelands Museum (the house was moved around the corner to Case Avenue. Several of the Wickham Brothers had a shipping business – owned a number of Lake Erie sailing ships – Also sold nets & other things to the fishing boatmen.  The Twine House at Huron, beside the river, was one of their warehouses.  Their ships went up into Lake Superior, etc. – Their ships were built up the Huron River, near Milan.

(1) History of Western Reserve, p. 1689, by Upton

(2) History of Western Reserve

(3) Records of Rhode Island

(4) Records of Rhode Island; History of Western Reserve.

(5) Told by Frank Wickham, who had it from his father.

(6) See Webster’s Biographical Dictionary, page 488.

(7) History of the Western Reserve, p. 1688-9-90).

(8) History of Western Reserve

(9) Told by Frank Wickham

NOTE: Agnes and Harriott cited their sources in the margins of original notebook.  I included these citations as footnotes, attempting to keep them as close as possible to where they appear in the original notebook.

I would appreciate critiques and corrections of this genealogy. Please comment below. Thank you.

© 2006, 2009 by David W. Barton. All rights reserved

4 Responses

  1. Very impressive research. Enjoyed reading it.
    Mine is just a comment in that I am a direct descendant of Sir Walter Blount & Sancha de Ayala who were the parents of Constance mentioned below:

    12. John de Sutton, died August 8. Henry IV in 1406 seized his father’s lands; married (2) Constance, daughter of Sir Walter Blount of Barton County, Derby.


  2. Thank you very much for your kind comment. I’m glad you enjoyed reading the story of the Sufferers’ Land.

    Dave Barton


  3. Would like to know how and why the name Sutton changed to Dudley.


  4. I live in Massachusetts and my family has for long time. I am a Sutton. Dudley, Sutton, and Winthrop are towns in mass. I am assuming we came from England and named these towns and were some of the first English to arrive.I hope my ancestors didn’t take part in slavery. that would be hard to swallow.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: